Blind Pew visits the Admiral Benbow Inn to give Billy Bones the black spot, indicating that Bones will soon die. He later returns with a gang of pirates, searching for Bones' treasure map. A lamp gets knocked over in the ruckus, setting the inn ablaze.
Pew is last seen wandering blindly through the flames, saying, "I think I smell something burning, no?". His fate is unknown.
Blind Pew, along with Black Dog makes a reappearance in 2014's Muppets Most Wanted at the gulag.